4.05.2006


The majority of Madison voters are giddy with delight today, inversely proportional to the minority who suffered a defeat this round. Anyone who knows me can probably figure out that I voted an affirmative on the referendum yesterday. But I feel that there's so much misunderstanding and obstinance across party lines on this issue, and on the "pro/anti-war" ideological conflict in general, that it is worth discussing just how I came to my decision, and what I think about this on a daily basis.

Anyone who decides to put their life at risk to go to war will have their own reasons for doing so, each as personal and individual as the next. They should be respected and honored for their choice. I hold my friends, family and community members who have done so in highest regard.

People who choose to abstain from enlisting for service are similiarly diverse in their ideologies, and should be similarly respected for their decisions.

My upbringing put me squarely in the peacemaking camp. I was taught that hurting other people is just not OK, whether you're using your body to hit someone on the playground or a weapon to take someone's life. My parents believed that this is an infraction on the love of God. But as I grew into an adult and started picking up each piece of my childhood to examine, keep or discard it's value, I struggled and struggled with this one. I should say, rather, that I struggle, present tense. First, there's the problem of rightoutsness; in most cases, the lines of right and wrong are entirely enigmatically subjective, so dependent upon your simple point of view. Though it is important to process ideas as a society, I have a real issue with warring for something based upon fickle human thought, something so personal as an idea... but I don't want to run away from duty.

Let's say that we do have a cause that is definitely beyond doubt a noble one (I guess unseating Hitler is fairly indisputed, in recent history) -- there's a vital piece missing to the (well-deserved) icon of Heroic Soldier; while I have no problem dying for a cause that is rightous, I do have a problem killing for such a cause, or any cause for that matter. "They'll get us if we don't get them first". Perhaps. Maybe they're saying the same thing. If we enter into this parry, we have become the same as the opponent... but again, is is right to run away?

AGAIN, I'm not saying that the soldier is a villian. That is as useless as saying that the peacemaker is the villain. "Support Our Troops". Hell, yes. They're over there in a dragging occupation, killing and being killed for questionable purpose. I'd say they probably need all the support they can get. The abstainee shouldn't treat a soldier as a third class citizen just because s/he was doing what they believed was right to fulfil their duty. Nor should the soldier treat the abstainee as a traitor. There are many ways to stand up for what you feel is right.

I think both methodologies can agree on one thing -- doing nothing is not OK. North Americans live in a cake society wherein we have a set of "God-given" rights which *supposedly* don't require any extra effort. That's usually an illusion - health care, housing and food cost resources (money), equal treatment under the law requires the intellectual rigor to remove prejudice... These are just a few examples; the point is, if you believe in system X, do what you're able to make sure that system X is at least upheld, at best improved. Maybe it's enlisting. Maybe it's going to law school to work for justice. Maybe you become a monk and work for peace. Maybe it's a lot of small steps each day. I hope that I will have made a difference doing what I do, but I will admit, I do not yet know what that will be.

The values we care about the deepest,
and the movements within society that
support those values, command our love.
When those things that we care about so deeply
become endangered, we become enraged.
And what a healthy thing that is! Without it,
we would never stand up and speak out for
what we believe.
--Fred Rogers

No comments: